
The biggest story of the moment is the Democratic Party’s performance in the midterms. Here in Texas, Gina Hinojosa beat Greg Abbott, James Talarico beat Ken Paxton, Vikki Goodwin unseated Dan Patrick, Nathan Johnson is the next attorney general, and Democrats flipped the Texas House for the first time in over two decades.
Overnight, the political dynamics for the state have totally inverted. Where before we had a solidly red state government, which was often at odds with the blue cities, there is now a significant presence in Austin that will be receptive to city leadership. For San Antonio, it is the first time in our city leadership’s political lives that state government is not an adversary.
Abbott’s much maligned plan to break municipal control of CPS Energy is dead. The long march of legislation restricting Texas cities, from the 2019 revenue cap to the 2021 “defunding” statute, is likely over, for the moment. Nothing like that will likely worm its way through both chambers. The governor also appoints the people who run the agencies with tremendous importance to what we get done: the Transportation Commission that decides what happens on I-35, the Public Utility Commission, the education commissioner who decides which districts the state takes over, the water board, the UT regents who will shape the merged UTSA.
Democrats, used to playing defense in Austin, will have a governor’s office, a House majority, and agency heads receptive to their policy positions. Even better, they’ll probably be easier to work with. And for local Democrats specifically, the automatic veto on their agenda in Austin is gone, giving San Antonio an advantage it has not had in a generation.
So… Mission accomplished, right?
Not quite. While this is a political difference for us here, and it will probably help us somewhat, it doesn’t solve our problems for us. In fact, we remain totally burdened by our most fundamental issues: conflicted leadership and a lack of vision & transparency. In sum, we remain our own worst enemy.
Our problem was never that leadership in Austin didn’t like us. Every big city in Texas had to deal with a Republican government, and much of its ire was aimed at Austin, not us. But Austin saw tremendous growth anyway with GDP up 39 percent from 2018 to 2023 and 81 corporate headquarters relocations since 2018. Dallas and Houston, under the same state leadership, did just fine, too.
It could be argued that a sympathetic state government could alleviate some local problems. An increase in school funding could help stave off school closures, or they could even try to repeal the voucher program. Expanding Medicaid. Loosening the 3.5% revenue cap. Mail every household the $1,500 check Hinojosa promised out of the rainy day fund. Some of it will be attempted, and very small pieces of legislation with this flavor could sneak through. But remember: the Senate is still firmly GOP controlled.
A split Legislature is an environment where very little legislation without tremendous bipartisan support is likely to reach the governor’s desk. The lt. governor, typically very powerful, will preside over a chamber whose majority can rewrite its rules to decide just how powerful she is. What the new state government can do for San Antonio, in other words, is mostly listen and stop targeting us, which doesn’t fix things at home.
The issues at hand are numerous, and all local. Our general fund grew from $1.1 billion to $1.7 billion in a decade. A records system that misses its own deadlines and sits on the attorney general’s orders. Sixteen chambers of commerce and no strategy, in a city whose consultants listed “lack of vision,” “too many organizations operating in silos” and “perception as not business friendly” among the weaknesses within its control. Nonprofit contracts nobody has audited supporting, in part, a $236 million workforce program that produces mediocre results. School districts facing structural enrollment decline. A ballpark that can’t secure financing. And, yes, a dysfunctional council. None of this was because of Greg Abbott, and Gina Hinojosa isn’t going to fix it.
And these new leaders don’t owe San Antonio anything. The governor represented Austin in the House. The lt. governor represented Austin. The comptroller was the Travis County judge. The new U.S. senator represented Round Rock and then Austin. San Antonio’s kindred spirits in state government are almost entirely politicians from the city that has spent fifteen years taking what we wanted: the headquarters, the venture capital, the direct flights, and ultimately the state’s (and the country’s) attention.
Our leadership has spent a long time playing defense against the state. Beyond the avoidable spats with the state over Chick-fil-A in the airport and rainbow crosswalks, the city has sued over the preemption law, fought the revenue cap, asked the Legislature to leave its annexation powers alone, and has ultimately measured each session by what it stopped. The school districts went further and made the Legislature the explanation for everything—even last week’s results. Now there is nothing left to stop, and there will be a temptation to wait for the Legislature to fix our problems for us. But beyond the headline, nothing has really changed.
The city should use the next two years to do what it could always have done. We could consolidate the economic development ecosystem, invest in real transparency, and make the hard decisions in pursuit of new opportunities for growth. But the trend suggests otherwise. San Antonio was one of the poorest big cities in America under Ann Richards, under George W. Bush, under Rick Perry, and under Greg Abbott. It continues to be so, today. The common factor was us, not the governor, and now we can’t blame Austin.



Very good observations. Unfortunately, we have had a "dysfunctional council" for a long time, well before the current one.
Spot-on insights on a city that can't decide if it will grow or stagnate.